从偏差到多样性:丹麦性教育五十年的话语和问题化
From Deviance to Diversity: Discourses and Problematisations in Fifty Years of Sexuality Education in Denmark
——原载《性教育——性、社会和学习》2022年第22卷第1期——
<Sex Education - Sexuality, Society and Learning> 2022, 22 (1)
【摘要】本文分析了丹麦中小学的性教育课程。从“问题是什么?”的政策分析方法中汲取灵感,我们探讨了风险、健康、生活质量、性的多样性和批判性教育学的话语如何同时渗透到课程政策中,并有助于产生特定的主体性学生和老师。随着时间的推移,不断变化的国家课程已经朝着更加集中化的方向发展,越来越关注学习成果,而不是更广泛的教育理想。对当前课程的分析揭示了三个被边缘化的话语:关于快乐和性感的话语;关于LGBTQ+问题的讨论;以及关于种族、文化和宗教多样性的讨论。丹麦国家性教育课程产生了两种截然不同的学科立场:一方面,需要保护的不知情的学生,另一方面,要支持有能力、负责任和能动的学生。性教育的后现代和批判性方法可能会消除某些主体性的空间,同时为新形式的代理规范批判性主体性开辟空间。[关键词] 性教育、学校、课程政策、话语、丹麦
[Abstract] This article analyses the sexuality education curriculum in primary and lower secondary schools in Denmark. Taking inspiration from the ‘what is the problem represented to be?’ approach to policy analysis, we explore how discourses of risk, health, quality of life, sexual diversity and critical pedagogy simultaneously permeate curriculum policy and contribute to the production of particular subjectivities among pupils and teachers. Over time, changing national curricula have moved towards greater centralisation with increased attention paid to learning outcomes rather than to wider educational ideals. An analysis of the current curriculum reveals three sidelined discourses: discourses on pleasure and erogeneity; discourses on LGBTQ+ issues; and discourses on ethnic, cultural and religious diversity. The Danish national curriculum on sexuality education produces two contrasting subject positions: on the one hand, the uninformed pupil in need of protection and, on the other hand, the empowered, responsible and agentic student. Postmodern and critical approaches to sexuality education risk eliminating room for certain subjectivities while opening up space for new forms of agentic norm critical subjectivity.
[Key words] Sexuality education, Schools, Curriculum policy, Discourses, Denmark
论文原文:Line Anne Roien, Christian Graugaard & Venka Simovska (2022). From Deviance to Diversity: Discourses and Problematisations in Fifty Years of Sexuality Education in Denmark. Sex Education - Sexuality, Society and Learning, 22 (1) : 68-83.
https://doi.org/10.1080/14681811.2021.1884060